Such an amateur…


Amateur: A person who engages in a study, sport or other activity for pleasure rather than for financial benefit.

Professional: A person engaging in a specified activity as one’s main paid occupation.

“The amateur works until they get something right.

The professional works until they can’t go wrong.”

Julie Andrews

Last week, my sister Anna and I went to see an amateur production of ‘Rent’. Our friend Sophie was playing Joanne and Anna has known the show’s director for years. I’m not going to write a review of the production…but I will say that I was incredibly impressed. All of the principal characters just ‘got it’. I didn’t sit there thinking “Oh, they are acting-schmacting”. I believed them. The ensemble singing was slick and powerful too. That ‘amateur’ company had adopted a professional attitude and put on a bloody good show.

Chatting to my Anna after seeing the show made me think about amateur vs. professional theatre. Anna, Sophie and a number of other friends are extremely talented performers who put their heart and soul into working on amateur theatre productions. They pay their society subscriptions and love being part of the process from rehearsal to ‘show week’ with no pay cheque at the end.  Anna, knowing I’m itching to work (Cue “I really need this job” from A Chorus Line) said to me: “Why don’t you just do a show for fun?”                                                                                                  I responded: “Oh, I don’t know, I’m not sure if I’m supposed to do that…it might be frowned upon by my agent/casting directors etc…” (!!)                                                                   To which, by brilliantly bloody minded, red-headed sister said: “Bullshit! You don’t have to tell them anyway! Do you think it is better to let your training go to waste?!” Though she be but the little sister, she is fierce.

I have a BMus and MA in Music and a year’s professional Musical Theatre training to my name. I call myself a professional singer/actress/music and singing teacher. I earn most of my income from teaching singing. I have had one properly paid acting job so far this year and a smattering of unpaid work. As a late arrival to the musical theatre business, I’m finding it hard (impossible?) to get into auditions for West End shows. It’s even beyond tricky to get seen for fringe work that pays as little as £200 for a four week run. I know there are hundreds, probably thousands of talented performers in this very boat…and then there are hundreds who get into the audition room but miss out on the job…and hundreds who get a job but miss out on the next one. I was well aware of this when I made the decision to train in Musical Theatre. I’m not complaining. With odds like these why don’t I just give up? Because I don’t want to. I want to perform. I want to be paid to perform. But, I don’t want to wait.

As a ‘professional’ performer, it is easy to join the thumb-twiddling, madness inducing waiting. Waiting for the next audition. Putting your holiday plans on hold or not committing to anything more than temp work so you can be available for any performing job that comes along. There is no joy in waiting.

Agents/Casting Directors/Other industry types often warn new graduates off joining amateur dramatic societies. True, it is not appropriate to include amateur theatre credits on your professional CV. But is there any harm in practising your craft? What if there is a role that you would love to play professionally but you can’t get anywhere close to an audition for it?

Industry ‘powers that be’ are often positive about actors creating their own work. Putting on a small scale show with a few actors is (just about) feasible…but a lavish full scale production of a musical…not so much. There are well-established amateur musical theatre companies around the country that put on full scale musicals in top theatres. When I lived in Sheffield, I performed with two amateur theatre companies (STOS and Croft House) who put on shows in the Sheffield Lyceum (Sheffield’s receiving house). The production values and budget were significantly higher than a lot of profit share/professional theatre that I have seen or been involved in. The experience of performing in such an amazing space, with lots of talented people and a full band, was wonderful. The sense of community in amateur theatre can not be taken for granted: amateur companies will support one another’s shows, they show up for rehearsals and often they show up and help when times are tough for their members. Why do so many ‘professionals’ look down on this and refuse to be a part of it? Scared that you will be branded an ‘amateur’ for life if you play Eliza in Soandso Light Operatic Society’s production of ‘My Fair Lady’? How does doing nothing but waiting for that West End contract to drop into your lap make you more of a professional than someone who learns and plays a role for no money?

Paid performing jobs are scarce. There are a lot of us who are aiming to make a living in this crazy world of show business and there is not enough ‘top flight’ work out there for everyone. Most of us have ‘another string to our bow’ that is more lucrative. Ideally, that string is something that you enjoy and that allows you flexibility to take performing jobs. But while we are striving to find a ‘professional’ performing job we mustn’t lose our professional attitude. As Julie says, “A professional works until they can’t go wrong”. So get to work. Make your own work and keep going until you can’t go wrong.

I’m off to book a venue for ‘What Would Julie Do?’: the show and get working on that …and if anyone needs an Eliza…Cameron Mackintosh or Soandso Light Operatic…give me a call!




9 thoughts on “Such an amateur…

  1. Always a difficut call as a professional, when I became a dancer I made the decision that I would only dance for money. It is/was my work, what I did, how I earned enough money to keep my family alive. There are times of great angst and even today my father still thngs I ought to have had a proper job.

    As a dancer I got other dancers together along with other artists; experimental film, industrial musicians and created work where it was cheap or free (in the countryside, quarries and cliff edges of Sheffield.

    I make no claim that this is easy and I was not trying to break in to the West End or London scene. I still got to work with great choreographers and companies, ultima Vez, Stephen Petronio, DV8 and more.

    Seek others, be aware of your value and beleive on your ability.


      1. Go for it! Look forward to seeing what will happen. As a teacher I have often thought of using teh summer to create a peice of work – but iif all; dancers, musicians and artiists who have decided to use teaching as a way to supplement their Art did the same thing then there would be a very small audience to go round even more. X


  2. As a teacher and trainer of “amateurs”, I think that all performers and performances should aspire to being “professional”. Whether working with children or adults I hope to help them be the best they can be, and to give of my best too. Given the right challenges we can all raise ourselves to new heights of achievement – sticking within our comfort zones leaves us where we started. I’m so proud of my school choir (age 7-11) who gave a very professional performance this week – tricky songs performed to a very high standard with great focus, energy, care, dedication, discipline – nothing amateur about it, apart from them not earning money for doing it!

    To get back to the theme of your post, I think it’s vital to keep practising your craft somehow, whether paid (well or badly) or not, so that you are “match fit” when the big opportunities present themselves. You’re a class act – keep at it!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Rosie, great piece.

    When I was ‘pro’ amateurs were certainly looked down upon, because ‘pros’ had put all that behind them, and professional theatre was a deal less competitive than now. There were not the plethora of stage schools and conservatoires churning out new youthful talent, year after year.

    This increase in competition has led to a change of view by most in the profession: it’s now generally seen as beneficial to ‘keep your hand in’. So – go do amateur shows (as long as they’re willing to take the risk of you being suddenly unavailable due to getting professional work!), but just be a bit picky about who you choose to do a show with: make sure – as much as you can – that their standards and yours don’t clash.

    Yes, go for it, and the more you do, the more you’ll learn, the better you’ll get.


    1. Thanks for reading John! I agree with you! I will take any opportunity that will help me to grow as a performer!! Typically, after a *very* quiet month, I’ve got an audition for a UK Tour and a recording session booked in for next week! And so it continues… We soldier on!! Xx


  4. I read that a while ago… Very good points! I think it is important for everyone to give themselves permission to do something else/redirect their lives/career whenever *they* decide… A blog about that is coming soon!! 😉 Xx


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s